5. THE POLITICAL DOMAIN
Abu-Laban, Yasmeen and Daiva Statiulis.
"Ethnic Pluralism under Siege: Popular and Partisan Opposition
to Multiculturalism"
Canadian Public Policy
1992, 18, 4, Dec, 365386.
An examination of the current critiques
of the federal multiculturalism policy in Canada by academics,
the Spicer Commission, federal parties, & ethnic minorities.
Factors accounting for attacks on the policy include the constitutional
impasse, along with a shifting, though resistant ethnic power
structure, & the fears linked to growing immigration &
refugee pressures from Third World countries in a global context
of economic decline.
Bell, David and Lorne Tepperman.
The Roots of Disunity. Toronto: McClelland and Stewart,
1979.
Black, Jerome H. and Christian Leithner.
"Immigrants and Political Involvement in Canada: The Role
of the Ethnic Media." Canadian Ethnic Studies 1988,
20, 1, 120.
The role of ethnic media in immigrant
political involvement in Canada is examined. An integrative perspective
envisions those institutions introducing host society norms to
the newcomer, & facilitating their learning of Canadian norms
of political discourse. An alternative approach anticipates negative
correlations between ethnic media & political involvement,
because ethnic institutions envelop the immigrant in a web of
groupcentered information, restricting messages about the
new society. The consumption of ethnic media & the degree
of political involvement are examined using data from a 1983 survey
of immigrants in Toronto, Ontario (N = 469 Europeans & 176
West Indians). Some support for the integrative perspective is
found with regard to print media consumption.
Black, Jerome H.
"Immigrant Political Adaptation in Canada: Some Tentative
Findings" Canadian Journal of Political Science 1982,
15, 1, 3-27.
Black, Jerome H.
"Ethnic Minorities and mass Politics in Canada: Some Observations
in the Toronto Setting" International Journal of Canadian
Studies 1991, 3, 129-151.
Chui, Tina W.L., James E. Curtis
and Ronald D. Lambert. "Immigrant
Background and Political Participation: Examining Generational
Patterns." Canadian Journal of Sociology 1991, 16,
4, fall, 375396.
Data from the 1984 Canadian National
Election Study (N = 3,380 adults) are used to test the hypothesis
that immigrants participate less in mass political activities
than do nonimmigrants. Multivariate analyses reveal that birthplace
& length of residence show no particular effect on political
participation. Only generational cohorts relate to 2 of the participation
measures after controls. For some activities, the offspring of
immigrants show significantly higher levels of participation than
any other group. Thus, no support is found for the ideas that:
deeply rooted Canadians are the most participatory, there is a
progressive increase in participation with generations in the
country, & the Canadianborn are more politically involved
than immigrants.
Corbet, D.C.
Canada's Immigration Policy. Toronto: University of Toronto
Press, 1957.
Creese, Gillian.
"Immigration Policies and the Creation of an Ethnically Segmented
Working Class in British Columbia, 18801923"
Alternate Routes
1984, 7, 134.
Examined is the role of Canadian immigration
policies in the creation of an ethnically segmented working class
in preWWII British Columbia. The formation of an ethnically
segmented working class occurred through a complex & reciprocal
process of ethnic segmentation within the labor market & the
political & ideological practices of the working class. In
British Columbia, state immigration policies played a crucial
role in this process by according Asian immigrants, in contrast
to European & American immigrants, an inferior political status
as 'nonsettlers' within Canada, reinforcing their marginal
economic position within the labor market & placing Asian
workers in a position of economic & political inferiority
visavis other workers in the province. In this context,
immigration policies became a focus of class conflict in British
Columbia, & working class organization & consciousness
developed in an ethnically segmented & racist form.
Das-Gupta, Tania. "Political
Economy of Gender, Race, and Class: Looking at South Asian Immigrant
Women in Canada." Canadian Ethnic Studies 1994, 26,
1, 5973.
A political economic discussion of the
relationships among class, race, & gender & their impact
on the South Asian female immigrant groups working in Toronto
(Ontario) & Vancouver (British Columbia). The experiences
of both wageearning & noncompensated working women from
India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Sri Lanka, & Nepal are examined
against the larger Canadian context of capitalist labor processes.
While the government's immigration policies favor selected groups
as part of a strategy to encourage growth of an employable population
for the exploitation of the country's rich natural resources,
they also reproduce traditional gender relations, supported by
the patriarchal institution of the South Asian family.
Desbarats, Peter and Phyllis Giroux,
eds. Journalism, religion
and development. London,
Ont: Graduate School of Journalism, University of Western Ontario,
1990.
Dirks, Gerald.
Canada's Refugee Policy: Indifference or Opportunism?
Montreal and London: McGill-Queen's University Press, 1977.
Foot, David K.
"Canada's Unemployment-Immigration Linkage: Demographic,
Economic, and Political Influences" Canadian Journal of
Sociology 1994, 19, 4, 513-523.
Foster, Lois and Anne Seitz.
"The Politicization of Language Issues in "Multicultural"
Societies: Some Australian and Canadian Comparisons." Canadian
Ethnic Studies 1989, 21, 3, 5573.
The politicization of language issues
in recent decades in Canada & Australia is comparatively examined.
In Canada, the need to accommodate the French majority population
of Quebec resulted in official bilingualism, legislative prescription
& definition of multiculturalism, & an earlier entrance
of language issues into politics. The opposition between official
& nonofficial languages & the cultural interests they
represent is thus a source of political conflict. In Australia,
though linguistic diversity was never repressed, politicization
of language issues emerged only after abolition of the White Australia
policy; however, the less confrontational rhetoric of "access
& equity" in language policy was adopted, thus avoiding
the pitfalls of official multiculturalism.
Freeman, Gary P.
"Migration Policy and Politics in the Receiving States."
International Migration Review 1992, 26, 4(100), winter,
11441167.
The US, Australia, & Canada are
the only countries whose migration policies still permit mass
immigration, but Australia & Canada, & to a certain extent,
the US, are headed toward the more restrictive policies that characterize
other industrial democracies. Canada continues to expand intake
in the face of popular opposition, but the new migration program
gives the government more control over immigration management.
The crisis in the asylum system cries out for international cooperation,
but paradoxically, independent immigration policies are still
the norm.
Green, Alan G.
Immigration and the Postwar Canadian Economy. Toronto:
Macmillan of Canada, 1976.
Grewal, J.S. and Hugh Johnston, eds.
The IndiaCanada relationship: exploring the political
economic and cultural dimensions. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
Publications, 1994.
Hawkins, Freda.
Canada and Immigration: Public Policy and Public Concern.
Second Edition. Kingston and Montreal: McGill-Queen's University
Press, 1988.
Hawkins, Freda.
Critical Years in Immigration: Canada and Australia Compared.
Kingston and Montreal: McGill-Queen's University Press, 1989.
Johnston, Hugh J. M.
The voyage of the Komagata Maru : the Sikh challenge to Canada's
colour bar. Vancouver: University of British Columbia Press,
1989.
Kovacs, Tibor.
Exile forever? : the life story of a Hungarian immigrant in
Canada : historical and political study 19311989.
1990.
Li, Peter S.
"A World Apart: The Multicultural World of Visible Minorities
and the Art World of Canada." Canadian Review of Sociology
and Anthropology; 1994, 31, 4, Nov, 365391.
The hypothesis is developed that the
Canadian government's differential approach to dominant culture
& minority culture art has resulted in two worlds of art,
with different infrastructures & rules of operation. The highstatus
formal art world is dominated by European & North American
art forms & funded through the Canada (arts) council. The
lowerstatus multicultural art world has folkloric forms
with immigrant & minority participation, & is funded under
multicultural programs. Standards of evaluation are differentially
applied to the two art streams; multicultural performances are
often chosen & funded for political reasons, not artistic
concerns, & nostalgic or stagnant multicultural art is encouraged,
vs experimentation with new cultural expressions. The funding/patronage
bifurcation in the Canadian art world artificially divides art
forms & marginalizes the artistic development & products
of visible minorities. Although intended to be a corrective measure
for minority disadvantage, this system perpetuates the cultural
hegemony of Occidental values & culture in Canada.
Marr, William and Pierre L. Siklos.
"The Link Between Immigration and Unemployment in Canada"
Journal of Policy Modeling 1994, 16, 1, 1-25.
Matsuoka, Atsuko and John Sorenson.
"Ethnic Identity and Social Service Delivery: Some Models
Examined in Relation to Immigrants and Refugees from Ethiopia."
Canadian Social Work Review 1991, 8, 2, summer, 255268.
Data from the Canadian Employment &
Immigration Commission indicate that some 10,000 Ethiopian immigrants
& refugees have joined Canada's multicultural society since
1980. Four models of service delivery are considered: (1) generic
services delivered by mainstream agencies; (2) services provided
by ethnic organizations to their own communities; (3) multicultural
services addressing the needs of broad ethnic categories, eg,
African immigrants; & (4) the bridging approach, developed
by the Immigrant Access Service in Winnipeg, Manitoba, in which
mainstream agencies hire workers from different ethnocultural
backgrounds to serve clients from similar backgrounds. The advantages
of this model are outlined, especially the capability of providing
help in a nondiscriminatory manner, & strategies to aid its
implementation are suggested.
McNaughton, Craig J.
"Are the Humanities in Canada Too Eurocentric?" SocietySociete
1990, 14, 2, May, 1719.
A 1989/90 survey is reported that sought
to explore whether humanities scholarship in Canadian higher education
is too Eurocentric. Anticipating legitimate resistance to moves
to reform the Eurocentric orientation of humanities scholarship,
three considerations that make the survey necessary are identified:
(1) the ethical imperative to ensure that aboriginal & minority
immigrant communities enjoy equitable access to postsecondary
programs of study & research focused on their cultural or
humanities traditions; (2) the economic & political utility
of capitalizing on individuals who have the ability to understand
& function within the languages & cultures of nations
with which Canada must trade & negotiate; & (3) the pedagogical
value of exposing students to nonEuropean ways of perceiving
& managing the world.
Pal, Leslie A.
Interests of the State: The Politics of Language, Multiculturalism
and Feminism in Canada. Montreal and Kingston: McGill-Queen's
University Press, 1993.
Polyzoi, Eleoussa.
"Psychologists' Perceptions of the Canadian Immigrant before
World War II." Canadian Ethnic Studies 1986, 18, 1,
5265.
An examination of the image of the immigrant
as portrayed in Canadian psychological & mental health literature
before WWII. It is argued that members of the early Canadian psychological
profession, as reflected in their research, were influenced by
the social & political attitudes of the times. The immigrants,
particularly those from southern & eastern Europe, were cited
as a problem, as a contaminating element, if not to be excluded,
at least to be biologically amalgamated. Psychologists, in their
anxious concern over the impact of the immigrant influx on the
dominant AngloSaxon character of the population, often served
to influence the government through their research to develop
more restrictive immigration legislation.
Prymak, Thomas M.
(Thomas Michael). Maple leaf and trident : the Ukrainian Canadians
during the Second World War. Toronto: Multicultural History
Society of Ontario, 1988.
Reitz, Jeffery G.
The Survival of Ethnic Groups. Toronto: Mc-Graw Hill Ryerson,
1980.
Souglobin, Sergei.
"Ethnic Politics in a MultiEthnic State: Canadian Immigrant
Communities and Political Process." Migracijsketeme
1991, 7, 1, May, 4758.
The relationship between ethnicity &
politics is explored for the modern multiethnic federative state
of Canada. Emphasis on group politics encourages the analysis
of each component in the political functioning of ethnic communities.
In this light the political representation & organization
of Canadian ethnic structures is discussed by defining the contextual
scope of potential models of distinctively ethnic political behavior.
Ethnic patterns in political participation are increasingly vague,
showing rapid & efficient ethnic mobility & integration.
The low profile of internal ethnopolitics seems to be counterbalanced
by the highly promoted but depoliticized ethnic pluralism in external
Canadian ethnopolitics.
Samuel, T. John, P.M. White and J.
Perreault. "National
Recording Systems and the Measurement of International Migration
in Canada: An Assessment." International Migration Review
1987, 21, 4, winter, 11701211.
A critical assessment of the adequacy
of Canada's statistical sources on immigration & emigration
for both scientific study & policy needs. Discussed are the
relationship between immigrant data collection systems & immigration
policy, & the importance of political considerations in the
establishment of immigrant data collection systems. Special attention
is given to the statistical sources that apply to the various
categories of migrants.
Satzewich, Vic.
"Racism and Canadian Immigration Policy: The Government's
View of Caribbean Migration, 1962-1966" Canadian Ethnic
Studies 1989, 21, 1, 77-97.
Satzewich, Vic.
Racism and the Incorporation of Foriegn Labour: Farm Labour
Migration to Canada Since 1945. London and New York: Routledge,
1991.
Simmons, Alan B.
"Canadian Immigration Policy in the Early 1990's: A Commentary
on Veuglers and Klassen's Analysis of the Breakdown in the Unemployment-Immigration
Linkage" Canadian Journal of Sociology 1994, 19, 4,
525-534.
Simmons, Alan B. and Kieran Keohane.
"Canadian Immigration Policy: State Strategies and the Quest
for Legitimacy" Canadian Review of Sociology and Anthropology
1992, 29, 4, 421-452.
Veugelers, John W.P. and Thomas Klassen.
"Continuity and Change in Canada's Unemployment-immigration
Linkage" Canadian Journal of Sociology 1994, 19, 3,
351-369.
[Back] [Table of contents] [Forward]